Surgery-free relief for thumb arthritis

A person's hand shown from the thumb side with bones drawn on it in black marker.

Posted 10/6/2022

Busting the myth that nothing can be done to treat hand and thumb arthritis

  • 58+ million adults are affected by arthritis (1 in 4)
  • 57% of working adults (18-64 years old) are affected by arthritis
  • Arthritis is the leading cause of work disability in the U.S.
  • Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common type of arthritis

As someone who provides care for people with osteoarthritis, my heart sinks at those numbers from the CDC. The sheer number of people impacted by arthritis is disheartening.

And as a hand therapist, I often have people tell me that they are having issues but “know there is nothing that can be done about it.”

Osteoarthritis of the thumb affects the base of the thumb, where the thumb meets the bones at the wrist. Over time, and as we age, the cartilage in this joint breaks down.

Sometimes called "wear and tear" arthritis, OA was once thought of as something that we just have to deal with.

Well, I can say that's no longer the case.

While we can’t change the wear and tear on our cartilage, we can reduce the resulting symptoms.

What are the symptoms of hand and thumb osteoarthritis and what can help?

  • Pain
  • Weakness
  • Swelling
  • Stiffness
  • Loss of motion
  • Loss of function

With a lot of research in recent years, we now understand that OA is more than just cartilage breakdown.

OA also involves the fluid in the joint, as well as the ligaments and the muscles that support the joint.

Age, gender and genetics all play a part in the onset of osteoarthritis. And while there's not much we can do about those, the good news is there are things we can do. These include:

  • Reducing extra stress placed on our joints
  • Eating healthier
  • Doing gentle movement
  • Retraining muscles

An easy way to remember what helps reduce arthritis symptoms is a phrase often used by therapists, “Motion is Lotion."

How do I know it's time to do something about my thumb OA?

Because thumb OA usually is a gradual process and the changes are subtle, early symptoms can go unnoticed until you begin having pain or weakness. Increased stress on your joints adds to the factors contributing to what you experience as pain and swelling.

The base of the thumb is a unique joint. It gives us the ability to twist, pinch and grip. With OA, you may have stiffness that prevents pulling your thumb away from your palm.

On the other hand (no pun intended!), weakness causes your thumb to collapse. This makes it hard to twist off a lid, turn on a faucet or pinch buds in the garden.

If you're experiencing limitations in everyday movement, it's probably time to seek expert help.

A therapy program that treats the full spectrum of your symptoms can move you from saying, “Nothing can be done,” to saying, “How come I never knew therapy could be so helpful?”

Hand therapists are specially-trained in treating conditions of the upper limb. This includes the hand and thumb.

This advanced training makes therapists great partners in helping reduce your pain and restore lost function.

What can I expect in working with a hand therapist?

Your first therapy appointment will begin with a thorough evaluation of your hand and abilities.

With that evaluation, you therapist can help you see what's triggering your symptoms and coming up with a treatment plan. The plan will be unique to you and your specific issues.

Thumb arthritis is different for each person, and your treatment plan will reflect that.

Treatments and techniques can include:

  • Retraining your muscles to provide stability when you pinch
  • Hands-on techniques to improve motion and reduce pain
  • Changing how you do what you do – modifying behavior

This last one can be one of the more challenging aspects of managing your OA. But it’s critical in reducing stress on your involved joints.

Everything you and your therapist do has the goal of getting back as much natural range of motion as possible.

Therapy for thumb OA is designed to help you “work smarter, not harder.”

Therapists may introduce adaptive equipment or assistive devices into your care as well.

While those words may sound a bit "techy," the items themselves are quite simple but can lend a helping hand (again with the puns!) with your day-to-day tasks.

Some everyday items to make things easier include:

  • Using a wider pen for easier gripping
  • Using a jar opener instead of your hands
  • Using a coffee mug with a wide handle so all four fingers fit under the handle.

I’ve found that changing the tools used for gardening helps protect my joints but still lets me enjoy digging in the dirt.

close-up of a person's hand using shears to cut a plant in the garden

Spring handled shears reduce stress on the hand.

woman gardening

Ergonomic gardening tools reduce stress on larger joints.

You may benefit, too, from the short-term use of orthoses (braces or splints) in treating your thumb arthritis. This will keep the thumb in a neutral position and ease pressure on the joint while doing tasks that may trigger pain or discomfort.

Structurally, the thumb is designed like a column and under pressure if the muscles are not strong your thumb will “collapse."

A collapsing thumb reduces the strength to do pinching movements.

Just as we learn to use our core muscles when lifting, we can re-learn how to use muscles that stabilize the thumb column to perform grip and pinch motions.

close-up of a person's hand grasping an object

Thumb collapse during pinch due to weakness and too much joint mobility.

close-up of a person's hand with their finger being stretched by a therapist

Motor retraining can help correct the collapse.

close-up of a person's hand grasping a USB adaptor

Relearning how to use your muscles results in a stable strong pinch.

As you progress in therapy you will relearn how to use your muscles in a stable way.

The more you know, the faster you can dismiss the myth that there's nothing to be done about treating OA.

Admittedly, I initially thought this 15 years ago when I developed early signs of thumb arthritis.

Thankfully, we stand on the shoulders of giants who have done research to show the effectiveness of therapy.

I now use joint protection strategies and adaptive equipment. I use my “feel good” exercises when needed and my brace regularly. It has allowed me to continue the things in life I so love – cooking, gardening, mountain biking and working as a hand therapist.

Arthritis is a common condition.

While it's not preventable, you can take steps to help protect your joints to reduce the risk of further injury and discomfort.

Closing checklist

Take a quick assessment of the following:

  • Change in the appearance of your thumbs
  • Pain or aching at base of thumb
  • Loss of motion, stiffness or weakness while doing activities, especially when you pinch

If you notice a change in any of these, know that there is treatment to help you.

Talk with your doctor or click the blue button above to request a consultation with one of our therapists. Ask about our arthritis program and get started with your personalized treatment plan.

Article courtesy of Molly Hudson, O.T., CHT, COMT-UE, Hand Therapy Program Coordinator Houston, TX.